Their Daughter Was Missing. They Were Too Busy Fighting. | Caged Ch. 12–14 | Politics of Justice #23

Their Daughter Was Missing. They Were Too Busy Fighting. | Caged Ch. 12–14 | Politics of Justice #23
A Time to Thrill - Conversation with Aime Austin Crime Fiction Author
Their Daughter Was Missing. They Were Too Busy Fighting. | Caged Ch. 12–14 | Politics of Justice #23

Nov 20 2026 | 00:41:34

/
Episode • November 20, 2026 • 00:41:34

Hosted By

Aime Austin

Show Notes

About Politics of Justice: Politics of Justice is a long-form video series where I revisit my novels and unpack the personal history, legal realities, and systemic issues woven into the fiction. These conversations explore justice, race, family, power, and the cost of survival—on the page and in real life.

About Aime Austin: I’m Aime Austin, a legal thriller author and former trial lawyer. I write the Casey Cort and Nicole Long series, stories centered on women navigating broken systems and the moral complexity of justice. My work blends fiction, lived experience, and legal insight.

Find Me Online: Website: https://aimeaustin.com Substack: https://legalthrillerauthor.substack.com Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/legalthrillerauthor/ YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@legalthrillerauthor TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@legalthrillerauthor Bookbub: https://www.bookbub.com/authors/aime-austin Goodreads: https://www.goodreads.com/legalthrillerauthor

Listen & Subscribe: This series is also available in audio at A Time to Thrill – wherever you get your podcasts.

Music by John Bartmann https://youtube.com/johnbartmannmusic CC0

View Full Transcript

Episode Transcript

[00:00:06] Hi, I'd like to thank this episode's sponsor, Audible. [00:00:11] So, as I always say, I'm usually reading and listening to a book at the same time. [00:00:16] This month is no different. [00:00:19] It's November. You can see my gourds. I'm over here trying to be seasonal. So yesterday I started a book called Unreasonable Women. [00:00:30] It's not for the faint of heart. [00:00:33] I posted something recently on Instagram about it. It was talking about sexual assault allegations. [00:00:40] I. [00:00:41] Okay, let me say this. I'd recommend the book. [00:00:45] I started it. I. I read in bed before I get up in the morning. So I started it in bed yesterday morning and then I had to get up and go bike at the beach. [00:00:54] So I listened to it while driving to the beach and then also while biking and then driving back. So this is like two hours given traffic and then biking. [00:01:04] So what I will say is actually the audio is written by the author and for once it's okay. Sometimes I do not cotton with nonfiction authors reading their own books, to be frank. I think it's a way for publishers to save money by while also stroking the egos of authors. But often narrators and audiobook narrators are better at it because it's their whole job and they trained for it. [00:01:32] So that said, this one's actually okay. [00:01:35] So the narration's great. The. [00:01:40] How do I say this? The subject matter is interesting. What it is, is sad. So it talks about the criminalization of women's victimhood. And so she's doing this through three stories. I'm only through the first women's story. [00:01:56] Well, she sort of goes. And. Well, she intersperses from time to time. But the first, no, maybe I'm at the second woman. But these women, it's just so they're in prison. And she did this project where she decided to reach out to people in prison and interview them. Women in prison and interview them. [00:02:15] And a lot of the beginning is about who responded to her requests and how difficult it is to contact people in prison. I will say that because the only way I contact people in prison was as an attorney. I never had any difficulty because it's illegal to have difficulty. And nobody wants to mess with that, at least in my experience. [00:02:34] As soon as I said I was an attorney, I had no problems. [00:02:38] So what is interesting about the book is that the women that she's profiling who are in prison for what I think we would all most people could agree were self defense or killing in self defense. [00:02:55] It's just. [00:02:58] It reminds me a bit of Stephanie Wells and actually inspired me to think about writing a different book, sort of dealing with this. But what it is, is these are women who have been abused physically, sexually, from sometimes four, but very, very young ages, and can't get out of the cycle of abuse, don't have the education, the skills, the wherewithal, given how they've been treated by people mostly in their family as well as their parents, who try to downplay what had happened. And actually, in one of the women that she talks about, her mom was like, gung ho and prosecuting people who had abused her. And in that case, the system failed because. [00:03:48] Well, of course, she, like, you know, of course. Well, she. She met the guy and she knew him. So how could he have abused her or assaulted her? Oh, the stories are awful and too detailed. So I've been listening to that. So I took a break. I decided that I was going to spend yesterday afternoon after I was writing and then cooking and whatever, I decided I was not listening to that anymore. So this morning I started the newest Harry Bosch book, the Hollow. [00:04:16] So I love Harry Bosch and I love Michael Connolly's description of both Harry Bosch as well as the city of Los Angeles. [00:04:26] He describes the city of Los Angeles the way I perceive the city of Los Angeles. And that's not true for all writers or all books. [00:04:34] But he sees it or he describes it in the way that I live it, actually. Ironically or not ironically. Often I'm driving because I do listen. Often I'm driving in places that he's discussing as I'm driving. It happens so often. [00:04:51] Well, that I think he probably sticks to the same core of the city that I do. [00:04:57] So this is. [00:04:58] Let me say this. Well, I have some thoughts about the narratives for Vash over the years, but the narrator's fine. [00:05:04] And I started listening to it this morning while I was cooking again. And. And, well, I must have listened a long time because I was reading it a little bit last night and then I fell asleep because, you know, age. [00:05:20] But I've been listening to it and I just looked at the. [00:05:23] At the phone and I'm three hours in. [00:05:26] So clearly I've been listening much longer today than I thought. [00:05:32] So I do listen. I haven't driven anywhere. I am going to drive somewhere later today. And so to be honest, I'll probably finish the book tomorrow because I do have to drive and I'm just driving to Los Feliz to go to theater. But everything is a drive. [00:05:46] So it's. Let me say this, I have not been able to. [00:05:51] I read A couple of the Renee Ballard books, and I haven't been able to really relate to them. And then there's a new series that has two books. I, like, was looking up something, and I was like, oh, I've missed these. [00:06:04] And I started looking at one or listening to one. I actually don't know. I sometimes do both, and I just couldn't get into it. But the Hollow came out a few weeks ago, maybe a couple weeks ago, and I was happy to download it, because I don't know what it is about Harry Bosch, but I find him quite compelling. [00:06:24] And in this one, he's dealing with having lived for six years in a juvenile facility. Let's say that. So there's an infamous. It's closed. I mean, it really is closed. And the book talks a lot about this. [00:06:43] There was a juvenile facility for children who could not be placed or were not placed in foster care, but had nowhere to go. Originally, it was run by the probation department and was run similar to how a prison is run, which is obviously inappropriate for children who do not have criminal behavior. [00:07:01] And it was later turned over to the Department of Children and Family Services. [00:07:05] Not in the era that the character would have been there. [00:07:09] But, um, he does touch upon the huge lawsuit and settlement they had for the rife number of abuses that occurred in this facility. I don't mean to say that I heard my tone of voice. It is just that when you open these facilities that are full of children, it feels like it's also full of predators. [00:07:30] I don't. Maybe people who aren't predators. No, I should not say that I want to work with children. I. All I can think to myself is, I would never work in a place with children. [00:07:37] Just. [00:07:39] No, just too much. You know, you have, like, lists of things in life that you would never do. We always talk about how difficult it is to make choices in life. [00:07:48] And you people are like, there's things I wouldn't do, and one of them is probably work at any kind of juvenile facility. Like, I just wouldn't do that. I wouldn't be a teacher. Like, I have no interest in working with children. And I often think, well, maybe it's because I'm not a predator. And maybe the other people are like, I want children. [00:08:05] No, it's just. It's awful. [00:08:08] These two books, though obviously not about the same thing, are essentially about the same thing. It's always about these men predating on vulnerable people, women and children. It's kind of awful. [00:08:25] It's kind of awful. But I will say this so this is not the best read ad read I've ever done but I do still listen an audiobook and then I read on the Kindle. [00:08:39] I think the best way these days to enjoy a book because I spend a lot of time in the car just going nowhere. I literally have no miles on my car, but I spend a lot of time moving at a few miles an hour to get less than 10 miles. 99% of the time I don't go farther than 10 miles. [00:08:59] The airport's 11, honestly. [00:09:03] So with that said, I will leave a link below and I might leave actually a QR code. I'll figure that out how to leave a QR code for my audiobooks of which there are quite a few as well as obviously in paper and Kindle but it's it's the best way I know how to enjoy books these days. Switching back and forth based on what I have to do. The busier the life, the more the audio welcome to the Politics of Justice. It's me, your host, Amy Austin. [00:09:40] Let's get back to Cage. When I left off, we were at the beginning of chapter 12. It's a miles chapter and it's, it's. I. I don't know, I. It's interesting. So it's chapter 12 miles July 17, 2004 the first line is. You're the parents of Kelly Tucker? Valdispino asked formally. He shook the mother's, then the father's hands before scraping the metal chair legs against the floor and seating himself at the table. [00:10:10] Yes, I'm Courtney. This is Elliot, my ex husband, the mother said, putting a lot of emphasis on that tiny prefix. She was small, mousy and very nervous. [00:10:19] So as you may recall in one of the earlier chapters, they, well, they rescued a bunch of women and girls from the sorry container. And what this chapter highlights is that one of them was a girl named Kelly who went from. [00:10:42] So she is from Illinois. And Miles is really struggling with it because he said, I wanted to know why it had taken them more than a week to make it from Illinois to Ohio. Maybe they'd come by Stagecoach. [00:10:56] So the parents have come in to claim their daughter, ostensibly, and the first thing they do is they ask about this feno what's going on because they don't want to go in and talk to her. [00:11:11] And then he asks how. Miles asks how long she's been missing and the parents look at each other and don't answer. [00:11:19] So long story short, unfortunately, is that the father had custody of the child over Christmas and He has a new wife and a new baby and didn't notice that his daughter was missing for three days. [00:11:35] And the mother is really, really, really salty about it. [00:11:39] And it's. [00:11:42] The whole thing is actually just sad because it's a whole chapter about how this girl was not missed. And so it is, I don't say easy. [00:11:55] It is plausible to understand how responding to someone online was. And going to see a guy was more compelling than staying at home. [00:12:09] And she was gone for eight days before she was reported missing. [00:12:13] And she basically got online, met a guy, and he trafficked her. But it's, you know, and I just talked about this in the intro when I was talking about some new things I'm reading and listening to. But it's indicative of a broader problem where girls are victimized and ignored. [00:12:37] And it's a spiral of victimization being ignored, victimization being ignored. And Ms. Kelly is no different, despite the fact that she has white suburban parents. [00:12:51] And the main thing they learn in this chapter is that they need to find the sledgehammer who's the mastermind, because the middle guy, whoever it was who trafficked, who's similar to the beginning, like Dion. It's just similar to people who sort of find these girls and move them into being trafficked are in the same way as, like, I guess, low, low level drug offenders. [00:13:27] They are the levers, but they're not the whole piece of the man. [00:13:35] He says the last line is the middleman was a corner piece of the puzzle and we needed him. [00:13:40] So. And then maybe they can get to Sledgehammer. Who's to say? [00:13:45] So we move on to chapter 13. It's a Casey chapter. It's July 19, 2, 4, and Casey is in the federal court building, a place where she never wants to be. But as you may remember, she has that client who has a forfeiture. Forfeiture case. [00:14:01] And that's the reason why she's there. But she runs in the miles and she says. A little shiver went through me at the sight of him. We stood there two feet apart for a long, awkward moment. Finally, he reached and patted me awkwardly on the shoulder. Because even though they're, I guess, sort of dating, and they had the one date that ended in this horrible disaster of finding these women in the container, it's still. [00:14:27] I don't know if people do this today. I know people do this today. It is still an awkward situation where these people are in court in a professional setting and therefore cannot betray any deeper relationship. [00:14:45] So she's talking about, you know, that they're in court and they're due. [00:14:50] She's due. [00:14:52] And Miles apologizes for having bailed on her because one of the vic's parents came into town and Casey's thinking that she would like to try out a relationship with him, and he asks her out again. But in the background is this case, and it looms large. And I think that maybe one of them needs to do to civilian, now that I think about it, because this is a lot to separate from a budding relationship. [00:15:28] So she's in court on this. It's called an in rem action, the forfeiture. [00:15:35] And it was. It's very prescribed. So state court is. And still to this day, I was there with somebody recently. It's still a little bit loosey goosey and on the informal side of formal. Federal court is on the formal side of formal. [00:15:57] And, you know, Casey is. I don't say she's struggling, but she's in there. The judges like, your paper is there in order. She was like, my client was caring $20,000. [00:16:10] And the judge is like, well, this says 18. Are you. Are you claiming the United States has falsified its papers? And you never want to claim that. This is the hardest part about calling out corruption or any kind of police misconduct, because you're in the place that is the law and order place, and misconduct does occur. But the minute you call it out, everybody's like, everybody's an angel. Everybody's an angel. And they're like, you know, we don't. [00:16:42] Everybody's an angel. Are you saying that they're the devil? And unless you have, like, a mountain of evidence this high to suggest that the people are the devil, then you are seen as the loosey goosey, like, criminal defense attorney who's calling out a system that is otherwise a paragon of virtue, which clearly it is not, because otherwise you wouldn't have the Innocence Project. But yet, here we are. [00:17:06] It starts with the presumption. You know, there's theoretically a presumption of innocence, which obviously doesn't really carry over in court. [00:17:12] But there's also this presumption that things are on the up and up. No matter how many times corruption and wrongdoing come out, you still walk in. You can be arrested yesterday, you go into court today, and they act as if everything is normal. It's like it's a mind, is what it is. It's like. It's like. It's like the worst, like gaslighting. [00:17:35] Anyway, so they're saying that the DEA said that there's trace amounts of cocaine on the currency, and one that Casey points out, which I looked up years ago. I don't even know what context. Hopefully it wasn't. Maybe it was the criminal defense context that a majority of. Or at least, well, let me say this half of US Currency is contaminated with cocaine. [00:17:58] So it's crazy. So it's been somewhere between 50 and 80%. But it's like, literally crazy that because there's so much cash in the drug trade that everything is contaminated. But it's a way that, at least at this time, that the United States could, like, hook on, and they'd say, well, you clearly must be in the drug trade even though the bills are contaminated, even though, like, the majority of bills are contaminated anyway. It's just. It's just this hard, hard, hard thing. [00:18:28] So the problem that she has in this case is that her client needs to show the origin of the money. [00:18:33] And this is what. So clearly, if he is or was in the drug trade, you can't show a legitimate origin of the money. [00:18:42] But. [00:18:43] So that's true. That is 100% true. But the other issue is, is that if you are like a person, let's say you get paid tips now, but nowadays everything's a little tip machine. But let's say you get paid tips and you keep your tips bundled and you put them in a drawer. You did come by the money legitimately. Whether or not you pay taxes on it is a completely different crime. [00:19:08] But you came up with money legitimately, but you don't have a way to show how you came with the money. And this is actually, like, this is an issue, I think comes up even now. There's all the people I know who are like, I only leave cash tips because I don't believe that the tips actually go to the. [00:19:22] To the wait staff, which is actually. This came up recently, and somebody asked the wait staff, and they said they never get the tips. And, well, that's illegal. [00:19:32] Different. Different thing. [00:19:35] So it's. It's. There's any number of ways to come by cash that are legitimate for which you will not have receipts. [00:19:46] And so the judge says. [00:19:48] So she says to him, it means that you aren't getting your money back unless you can show how you got it. And Singleton was quiet as we made our way to the exit door. And he said, that isn't fair. [00:19:57] She was like, that's not fair, but is it the law? [00:20:02] And he's like, so it's just like that. The ATF can have my money. I Have to prove where I got every last time. They don't have to prove that it was involved in drugs. And I nodded and it was exactly like that. It was a game of poker with the government and they held all the cards. [00:20:18] And this is where Casey gets cynical because she says, a couple of years ago, I would have stood in the hall holding my client's hand as they wailed at the unfairness of it all. But I had another case to handle. If I wasn't in judges Bernie, Judge brody's room by 11 on the Jared Carter defense, he might just revoke my client's bail despite me. [00:20:36] And she says, because if I knew one thing about the Brodies, they were all about the spite. So, and this is true, like the number of clients who have railed about the unfairness of the system. And there's nothing to be said about it. Yes, it is often unfair. [00:20:57] And so you have to do the best you can in a system that doesn't benefit you. [00:21:02] So she moves on. So she gets moving on. So she goes to the. [00:21:08] Leaves federal court and goes to state court, which is the justice center, which holds in this case it's civil and criminal. But in the case, she's there for a criminal that day, and she's there with Jared Carter, who as we know, runs the place to be and whatever the other bar is called. [00:21:28] But let me say this. Oh my God, there's such a hierarchy. There's such a hierarchy. There's so many hierarchies. People love a hierarchy, don't they? [00:21:36] So everybody knows that federal court generally is considered more important than state court because of that formality. So like it starts on time. You're not futzing around like state court starts. When it starts, the judge walks in. When they walk in, they take cases and whatever they want. Like, it's like very like loosey goosey. If you've ever been a state courtroom, like there's like a 15 million moving people around. [00:22:00] And federal court is not like that. If people are moving around, they're moving around outside. Um, so she says, I, when she says, I got up in federal court and they said, don't worry, Judge Brody's been waiting for you. Um, and so she goes and gets her client and they're basically having a pre trial conference trying to decide when they're going to have a trial. So when you're indicted, if you have no filmmaker hearing or no evidentiary hearing, then you can and, and discovery has been exchanged, you can go to trial. How much time you need for trial prep. And the court's calendar and attorney's calendar. Well, mainly the defense attorney's calendar. The prosecutor. They have an entire office of, like, hundreds of people. Their calendar is always free, so. [00:22:42] Or they're always available. [00:22:44] So she comes in, and the prosecutor is Nicole Long. I believe this is the first introduction we have to Nicole. [00:22:53] And she says. [00:22:57] So Cole comes in and says, nicole Long, your client ready to plea? [00:23:03] And Casey's taken aback by Nicole's directness. [00:23:07] And Nicole's like, we haven't. Dead to rights. You should know I have a 98% win ratio. So prosecutors used to say this to me all the time. They'd come in and they'd say, your client ready to plea. They offered you nothing. They. They want your client to plead to the charge and the indictment, which is good for no one. [00:23:26] So they want your client to plead the charge in indictment. And they. That's what they start with. They start with no offer of just having your client plead guilty. I don't know if people do it, actually. I don't know. I don't know. I wouldn't do it because it's a negotiation and you can't do that, so. [00:23:42] And the 98% win ratio is always true. Actually. I hear it's not true in LA because a lot more clients go to trial, but whatever. [00:23:52] In, like, the majority of courts, it's true because the majority of clients plea. [00:23:57] Most people who are accused of a crime do not go to trial. They plead to some lesser charge in the hopes of doing less time and, well, doing less time and having a lower charge or whatever. [00:24:16] Have a lot of thoughts about that. I do think. I think clients should take. I. Well, okay. I think the best pushback against the system is that every case should go to trial because I think prosecutors should be put to their proof. [00:24:30] I have found that prosecutors are more intimidating than full of proof often. [00:24:35] And so if you threaten to go to trial, they will. They will. They will plea. Okay, none of that matters here, because this is a whole different kind of client situation. [00:24:48] So she says. Casey says, congratulations. [00:24:54] She said, I just wondered if it was in their playbook. After wearing a severely cut suit, the women always did dress like. I mean, okay, when I was there, it was like the Alan McBeal era. It's like, could you have a tighter pencil skirt? [00:25:08] I didn't ever know how they walk. Anyway, so she comes back and she. Judge Brody says, it's nice to see you. We missed you around the house. [00:25:20] She said, the greeting could have gone either way, but she's still in the Brody's good graces based on the deal that she made and ransomed where the family, if she denounced the family, the family wouldn't harass her. [00:25:33] So she throws a little smile to Nicole Long because in most courtrooms, the prosecutor is highly favored. And it's one time where a defense attorney has some little bit of a leg up because he's in the niece says, this is the best part for Casey. I, you know, this is, this is the best. This is just like a little like this is for me where the judge says to Nicole and your name again. [00:26:02] And she's like, Nicole Wong, I tried a case in front of you a couple years ago. And he squinted her and he goes, well, where have you been? [00:26:10] So the. And she says, in Child Support Enforcement, which like reels Casey back because if you go from felonies to cisa, the Child Support Enforcement Agency, the prosecutors work for them, then you know, something happened. And as will come out in the subsequent 12 books, Nicole has a little drinking problem and that was how she was punished within the prosecutor's office. [00:26:42] So, so getting all that, the judge says, is there a deal? Because that's the question. Because 98% of the time there is a deal. [00:26:51] And Nicole's like, he completed the charges as they stand. [00:26:55] And she said, if we please the day, we'll recommend concurrent instead of consecutive sentences, which means they would be served all at one time for all of the charges as opposed to stacked on top of each other. [00:27:06] But in. [00:27:10] Okay, Nicole is doing the prosecutor playbook and Judge Brody is not. [00:27:15] Because he says, did you forget in your absence, Ms. Long, that I have the sole discretion over sentencing? [00:27:20] And this is always true. But 95. Well, I don't know what percent of the time. Let me not say this. The sentencing is determined before the plea and it's determined with the negotiation between the prosecutor and the defense attorney and then with the input of a probation who does a pre sentence investigation or pre sentence report indicating what they think the best punishment or rehabilitation plan is for defendant. That's a separate issue we're not going to discuss. [00:27:54] So there's no offer. Casey hasn't made an offer. Her client's unwilling to plea and he, he wants to take the case to a jury and Nicole's unwilling to plea. So Judge Brody's flaring nose is the only indication of his displeasure. [00:28:12] Let me say this. So when I lived in Cleveland, every week, God, I think they came on Saturday, where these little like legal reporting booklets, booklets I don't know how to explain it. They were like this printed. They're like this turquoise teal little book that came with all the like cases, slip opinions, whatever that were reported. These are not all cases that would be like in a little casebook that you see, like if you're looking at TV and they have like these little law books. [00:28:49] But it was basically what had happened in the last week or so, I guess. [00:28:54] And one of the biggest issues is the, that in Ohio at that time, if a client pled, they got a better deal, a better, better sentence, better deal than if they went to trial. So if they pled to a charge, let's just say if second degree felony, which at the time was 2 to 10, they would, if they pled to 2 to 10, they'd be much more likely to get the 2 than the 10. But if they went to trial and were found guilty of the 2 to 10, they'd been more likely to get to the 10 part, usually an 8. [00:29:27] So seven or eight years. So it's, it is unconstitutional or whatever for judges to penalize people for going to trial. [00:29:39] And yet it happens. [00:29:41] So I want to say this, I'm saying this because the client's the. Let me say this. She knows this in her head. I don't even know what to talk about in the book. [00:29:52] So. But her client is determined to go to trial and the client's determined that like, that's not. You give them advice or not, but since there's no plea offer, then there's nothing. [00:30:03] Only thing to lose is more time in jail. But what, what is she going to do? Client wants to go to trial and that's his right. [00:30:09] So she, her client, you know, being. [00:30:13] How can I say this? Some defendants are really scared and some defendants have a lot of bravado. Jared Carter is more on the bravado end of clients. And he's like, I'd go to jail, I'd go to trial tomorrow. [00:30:23] Casey's like, I need six weeks. [00:30:26] And so the judge is like, you can either have novemb number after my civil trial or you can have three weeks from today. Because in. [00:30:34] This is not true in Los Angeles county, but because in Cuyahoga county, the judges, general judges or general jurisdiction handle both criminal and civil. Civil takes up a lot of time. [00:30:46] And those, some of the, some of the, like, some of the cases are long. Like the, not the insurance defense cases, those usually went pretty quickly. But anything that required like proof, you know, they had a smaller jury, but they'd have like all these evidence presentations. These child school has two, three, three, four weeks because it's about money and corporations always have time to spend money rather than pay a judgment. [00:31:08] So you have to work around that. Criminal do have priority because of the limit of days that people can be in jail or free on bail. It's 90 if they're in jail, 270 if they're out. [00:31:24] But that said, it's still, you still have to fit in around. So this guy does not want to wait till November. And he said, or you can have a trial three weeks from today. [00:31:34] And her client's like three weeks. [00:31:40] So this is the thing. So they're talking about how many witnesses and whatever. [00:31:44] And he's like, okay, we'll set it for four days. Jury selection starts on Monday, August 9th at 10. [00:31:50] Casey says, I dutifully wrote the date in my calendar and red pen I used for court dates, closed the monthly book and tried not to throw up. [00:31:58] Three weeks preparing for trial for, honestly for this trial, it wouldn't be too bad as long as you don't have a lot of other cases to prepare for. But it's like really. And this, this is not that kind of complicated like issue with like DNA or blood or like other things. So it's not that, not that difficult. [00:32:17] But anytime like a trial's like right around the corner, at least for me, like you know, it does something to the body because you're just like, okay, now I have to go in front of a jury and represent my client. And juries are like the wild west. [00:32:37] And you have to know that. And clients can, what is the word I want be unpredictable. That's the best way to describe it. They can be unpredictable. So knowing all of that like makes Casey want to throw up. And I know why. So she's got like a hard nosed prosecutor, a judge who's probably friendly, but you know, the Brodies can turn on a dime. A client who is unpredictable and a jury who could do whatever. [00:33:07] And the, I think the hardest part, at least for me about jury trials is knowing at the end either your client goes free or your client goes to jail. And I'm sure I mentioned this before that at least for most clients, they even if they're out on bond or bail or whatever, they, once they're found guilty, they will take them out of the courtroom like in their suit to jail, to go to prison afterward, after the pre sentence investigation, they still do that, determine like where you're going to be and all that other stuff before the Sentencing, but they take you, like, right to jail. And it's just so. So you come in the door with your client, and you walk out of the door without a client. [00:33:51] And I've watched it. It happened to me, actually, just once, my lesson there. But it just. It's the most. [00:33:58] It's like, really wrenching to think that somebody who has this right to trial then is just going to go to jail, like, immediately. Don't pass, go. Don't collect $200. [00:34:10] So all of that's probably in the background, I was thinking as I was writing this. [00:34:14] So we're up to chapter 14 in this book. It's a Jared Carter chapter. It's July 19, 2004. [00:34:21] So he's going home to the house where he and his mom live. I believe they live in Cleveland Heights, which is. [00:34:31] What do they call them? An older suburb of Cleveland, an older inner ring suburb. So the houses are. Oh, my God, at this point, over 100 years old, I guess. [00:34:44] Yeah. [00:34:45] Anyway, so when I lived there, it was not now. And time is passing. [00:34:51] So the houses over 100 years old, they're primarily brick. They have big lawns. It's very like in a ring suburb, but they're all closer together than newer suburbs where there's bigger spaces around houses. [00:35:03] So he's going home to Cleveland Heights, and so I guess he runs these strip club sports bars, but also lives like a regular life. [00:35:16] So he's going home and there's a white delivery truck blocking his driveway. So he's got his. He's blaring on the horn, and he's thinking he should probably be worried more about going to jail. But he's been. Been lucky so far, and he didn't really think there was a lot of evidence. [00:35:35] So he's going through bills. [00:35:40] Finally, the truck pulls away and he goes in. So Alicia, the cousin who's caring for his mom, he asked where his mom is, and she's watching Passions. Oh, my God. It was, I want to say it's like a half an hour soap opera that was on NBC probably long, long gone. [00:35:56] My grandmother used to watch soap operas. I only ever watched, I think, all my children with her and then Santa Barbara. But the rest of them, I don't know how she could watch all of them dangerous. I don't know how she watched any of that anyway. [00:36:10] Poor lighting and slow storytelling. As long the same about soap operas. [00:36:15] So he was like. He was Alicia's like, so you're gonna have a trial from a jury like you see on TV 12 people in a boxing, if you're guilty or innocent. And Jerry Carter, who is over everybody, is like, of course I'm gonna do that. But I got a lawyer who's friends with the judge, so. [00:36:34] And so this is interesting to me because Jared Carter, I think, is more savvy than most defendants I had, for sure. He says, I read the paper like I'm always telling you to do. This lady was dating the son of a judge then she wasn't. Unless she's some kind of straight up slut, I don't think they'd hate her. [00:36:52] And that father's your judge? [00:36:54] He nodded. So he probably went to the arraignment room. [00:36:58] It was arraigned, got the judge assignment, and then did research on the best attorney for that particular judge, which is brilliant, honestly, like one of my smartest criminals. [00:37:11] He says, yep, picture like a flower. She had the kind of office that made me know she'd be grateful for the work. [00:37:17] And it's like three weeks. [00:37:19] He's like, I can't fool around with my business clothes and the shit hanging over my head. I'll put it behind me and get back to work. And the cousin's like, but what if you. You know, like. She's obviously like, what if you go to prison? He's like, look, I am planning to go nowhere. It's an unfortunate event that I gotta go a couple of years. It's all set. [00:37:36] He's got. I got somebody to take over the business. He said, I'll make sure the money gets to you, for mama at the house and everything. [00:37:44] And she says, I haven't met your second in charge. And Jared Carter's thinking that's because he kept. He keeps everything compartmentalized. [00:37:52] It didn't take for more than a few episodes of Law and Order to figure out that people didn't properly exercise the right to remain silent if the right hand didn't know what the left hand was doing. And there wasn't no hand snitching to the police. [00:38:02] This is Dreadnought sometimes. Oh, God. I was just looking. I'm like, many episodes behind in the svu. I don't know. I got kind of bored and I gave it up for a few months. [00:38:14] But I was just scrolling through Peacock, I guess, and there's already a new season started, season 28, I guess. It's read 600 episodes, which is something that probably won't happen again. It's interesting. The death of network television. [00:38:28] Anyway, so what is interesting to me, and this is actually. It's Mildly infuriating, but also really true. Like the prisoner's dilemma. Like, I feel like it's half the episodes. And it's like, if nobody talks, nobody goes to jail. But somebody always, like, gets scared and talks. Like, if nobody talks, no one goes to jail. [00:38:51] And I don't understand, like, and this is the true. For even clients I had, if everybody exercised their right to remain silent, we would have a completely different justice system. But I feel like a lot of clients, like, just walk themselves right into jail. [00:39:07] Anyway, I digress. So he is basically, you get a little bit of background on his life. [00:39:19] And what is interesting to me about this, and this is I actually, I remember being. I remember the inspiration, not the inspiration for this. I remember walking the dog. [00:39:32] I think there was a morning dog walk when I had this idea. [00:39:37] So what he decides Jarrett Carter in this chapter. And he says to her, you know the white. Those white serial killer vans you see on tv? He's on the phone with his second in charge and whose name was Grant, took a deep breath before speaking and says, yeah, what about him? He says, I need you to get me four or five, whatever you can get for about 100 GS. We're going into the delivery business. [00:40:04] So that is. [00:40:08] This book has a twist. And so I'm trying not to spoil the twist because I think it's. [00:40:13] I have written a couple twists. This is like literally my favorite, maybe my favorite twist that I ever wrote. [00:40:21] And I wouldn't want to spoil it. [00:40:25] So we will end there. But we end with Jared Carter going out buying what he calls my serial killer bands, which I do appreciate, saying that he and grand are going into the delivery business. [00:40:39] But he's a very savvy defendant, and that is really well exemplified in these chapters. So it's been great going over some of these issues in Caged. I've hit my half an hour allotted time. [00:40:54] So with that, I want you to, like, subscribe, share and hype the video if you can. [00:41:03] And I will. And Jared and Casey and Miles, as well as Nicole Long. We'll see you in the next one.

Other Episodes